Sunday, 9 March 2014

A rhetorical question

A rhetorical question
A favorite question of mine is- if you a patient has say LBP or PA shoulder should the patient be seen by a therapist and asked to get an appointment for 5- 10 days or get a package ( up to 15000rs in chennai) until endpoint of the disease or pain.
The question is why should they attend a PT department daily rather than taking some pain killer and doing the exercise at home if needed? Isn’t it cheaper to spend 20 rs on some NSAIDS and do some exercise at home!
Here are some of the answers I have got from PTs. They have to attend a PT session because of-
1.     Is it because- supervised exercise is needed or more important?
2.     US, SWD, IFT, manual therapy is better than NSAIDS
3.     The adverse effects are less in PT than drugs (really)
4.     Others- please specify---------------------------------------
Please comment you answer.
Love
Hariohm
If they think I'm going to stop at that stop sign, they're sadly mistaken! --Homer Simpson



Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Research Fraud

Research fraud:
The other day one of my grad students asked e a question-“how do you know the data the put up in research study (journal article) is true”. Even though the answer for the question can be simple from- I don’t know, to  complex “well the researchers will have academic integrity” and so on.   That got me thinking- can i answer the question of do i believe the data- in the Indian context. So, I just thought -well let’s just think about it. 
I went and looked into some research studies published in some journals from India (especially PT journals). I have some knowledge on how Phd is done in our country. I have been also privy to some raw data also collected by people who are doing Phd or finished it.  From these i can honestly say many of these data look very iffy and some downright fradulent.
Why- well many of them send their PG dissertation and it takes few days to publish in some of the Indian journal especially in PT or rehabilitation.  Again, you may ask what is wrong with it. Well most of PG dissertation is just cooked up data sitting in the loo or while watching cricket match. 
We all knew for long time PG data many a time was cooked up. We all just sat there and watched as PTs started cooking data and plagiarising the content. We all thought well this is victim less crime- no one is hurt and the guy wants to finish the course.
However, this all changed with many of us got into the rat race of publishing. People started sending their dissertation, data which they dreamed up to some journal which wanted content desperately.  PTs doing PhD – well most of them just write some numbers and they also publish it.
 The mafia of cooked data (the drug peddler if you think them as cooking meth) and the journal (the police who have to control the peddlers) became strong. Along come databases like CINAHL, PEDro etc which started to index these journals with it came, the victim in the crime.
As more and more people started to look into all the published data either as part of EBM practice or doing a systematic review, these data (cooked or uncooked) became vital.  What happens if i want to look into say- Burnstromm  or electrotherapy for pain- most of the data which is published in these journals give a positive result (sometimes huge) unlike the other published data.  Akin to saying crows in my town are white unlike other crows which are black.  This skews the answer or for people who do SR.  Which by the, way ruins the whole idea of science of medicine and EBM. We may also be coming to the wrong conclusion, a useless treatment like Brunstrom for stroke as useful.
PTs in India must develop – research and academic integrity and stop the crime we may perpetrate in making medicine unscientific.   The editors of the journals should be more vigilant, tougher peer review moreover; the PTs who know he/she was fraudulent in his/ her data collection should never publish it.

Facts are meaningless. You could use facts to prove anything that's even remotely true! --Homer Simpson

love
Hariohm



Wednesday, 19 February 2014

Random thoughts

Random thoughts 

The natural question I get when I turn back – is physiotherapy evolving in India?  When I went to college the treatment was simple, do your exercise – no fancy names (but of course the exercise where not adequate), and over emphasis on equipments.  Neuro-rehabilitation, was more advanced in the 90s at least were I went to college. Even though there was undue importance to passive movements. The treatment was always active, “Hands off” when making them walk and stand, train upper limb activity. We even have community walking as many of my classmates could agree. No nonsense key point, no synergistic movement nonsense. Back pain surprisingly my friend a EBP in LBP would have been proud, - consisted of exercise, and (over emphasis on) SWD (which come to think about has as good an evidence as any other up to date fancy named therapies like- SMT, MET and what other crap workshop you attended last week.
But sadly all went south as more and more crap crept into our thinking. Many PTs seem to think yes- we are learning manual therapy –written by every idiot and intelligent people. The Idiots I mean are the osteopaths and chiropractors and well some PTs. NDT, PNF, this exercise that exercise, eccelctive approach- that horrible quotation- “these are my tools in my tool box” , 1001 special test (hate the word makes me feel I am ordering dosai in the mess I ate when I went to college- I special dosai).
But sadly, zero importance is given to physiology, motor control ideas and theory, pain theories etc.  The other day I heard a idiot- a instructor in NDT saying normal movement of gait need core muscle strength- I was about to say to him- get the hell out our country and stop making my people more dumb (we are there to help them not learn anything keep them dumb we don’t need any help from you). Well he is an expert in CP- good save the children of India from NDT trained idiots.  

Let’s get back to basics- I mean emphasis- on educating the patient, active treatment, hand off the patient and understanding the disease and patient rather than some point or techniques.  

It's all over, people! We don't have a prayer! -Reverend Lovejoy  from The Simpons

Saturday, 1 February 2014

The intelligent therapist guide to being intelligent

The intelligent therapist guide to be intelligent
In the ever increasing list of workshop starting from pure crap like chiropractic, osteopathy and dry needling (acupuncture masquerading as new age Babel)  and modern pseudo-science like NDT, SI, MET etc. how to can a intelligent therapist keep his sanity?
These are the check list the “The Indian Centre for Evidence Based Neuro-Rehabilitation” ICEBNR people have come up with before and during the workshop you need to look for:
1.       Read the brochure – if the “expert is certified in the technique” other than a university well just avoid it- probably a waste of reading beyond it. Universities are leaning centers (even some of it is useless) and centers which certifies you are well you can fill in the blanks
2.       Alternate in treating, holistic are all catch phrase of modern  pseudoscience science- be careful
3.       Become a expert – after doing the course- well if you see the expert who claims that- kick him – no one can become a expert in anything in 2 days or 6 weeks except my cat which became a expert in shiting in 2 days
4.       "Hands on" are more than theory than kick yourself for wasting your time. Remember any monkey can learn the technique, but you can learn or teach science to a monkey
5.       See change in the same day, immediate relief- these are red flags if the expert or brochure claims this.
6.       Ask them for evidence- if they quote an article –go and read them- most of them will say the technique is not working - they have not read it so they are depending on you to not read it.  Classical example – go and read the NDTA associations page on evidence most of them will say it is not working except some half ass study they themselves did which says well we are not sure.
7.       Remember if the expert has done 25 courses in 25 countries that will not make him an expert automatically.
8.       If they claim it sure will work- and give you didactic advice be careful
9.       Red flag- if you haven’t heard of the physiology in your life- example cranio-scaral therapy- well it is a suture idiot – we know it can’t be moved. Kick him in his nuts.
10.   Don’t keep your mouth shut and come out and start complaining – start asking questions while in the course.
11.   Remember it is not rude to disagree with the resource person – it is good manners to keep the resource person and yourself honest.
12.   Well – the easiest of all things is to learn by yourself and all together not listen to any half assed expert.

Operator! Give me the number for 911! – Homer Simpson



Sunday, 5 January 2014

A ode to my teacher

A ode to my teacher
I used to think a teacher was a person who taught you stuff like stroke rehabilitation, Math, etc. Then i went to college and met Mr. Siva Chidambaram. He was my lecturer and the junior most of all my teachers. He was sort of a poor teacher when he went and taught in the class room. He would not write in the board, could not effectively hold the classrooms attention. However, when he taught bedside clinical issues he just transformed into Stephen Hawking explaining black holes to novice in theoretical physics. He was clear in his views made you want to do it then and there what he was asking to do.
His greatness was that he could teach me stroke or SCI, but the way he would make you “want” to learn more. He was telling us to always look forward with theories and techniques.  He was teaching us MRP in 92 when most of the world taught it meant a tyre company.  He would tell me to try mobilisation of the knee joint using techniques he and i saw in a book.
The best anecdote about my beloved teacher is when i started to do my ortho project in 5 semester for my under graduation.  Unlike know, those days the topics were selected by the teachers and we have to select one through lot system. Presto i pick Potts fracture. My teacher who was man bent on teaching me told me to go and refer “Watson and Jones – fractures and injuries. He added that it is the bible of traumatology and I should read this book for the project.
I go and open this book on Ankle injuries and in the first few pages it says- Potts might have made a mistake and blah, blah and they concluded the better terminology could be “Ankle injuries”. I go and show it to my teacher and he says well we have to change our title for your project. We go and show it to my professor after protesting for some time she also agrees. The lesson is they were able to change their views even when a lowly 5 th semester student showed some literature.
Sadly nowadays the teachers will not change their views even it came and hit them on their face. Some clinical are beyond repair they just won’t look for evidence. The standard answer they have is well it works for me and my patients. It is like saying to Newton huh! My apple went up so i am not sure your theory and proof is good enough for me.
Love
K Hariohm
Today’s homers quote
BARNEY: Hey, Homer; you're late for English!
HOMER: Pffft, English. Who needs that? I'm never going to England.


Saturday, 4 January 2014

Film songs theory part II


In continuing with my “film song theory”, the other off shoot of it is the so called ecclective approach. Some therapist can’t leave their song and dance routine they have come up with this idea called as ecclective approach.
What pray you may ask is ecclective approach? Well you take a bunch of treatment written before man went to moon and mash it all together and think well i am a genius.  The treatment commonly mashed together are PNF, NDT, SI, Brunstromm and other initials i have missed.
What is wrong with that you ask, adding you take the good from all the treatment? For example i will use NDT when the patient cannot move, use stimulus ideas from PNF and use what the heck cranio-sacral therapy to well make a fool out of me. The problem is these techniques were once the cutting edge in science- well in the 70s and 80s (of course cranio-sacral therapy was nonsense even then) but like everything else time and science changes.
These treatments physiological validity and clinical effectiveness has been over time been proved to be very limited. Hence putting two or more treatment with iffy evidence is not new improved treatment. The garbage ladies of our street collect the garbage from each of our house and put it in a large bin at the end of the street. Putting it all together in the end of the street does not make all the garbage into gold it just makes it into bigger garbage.
So we need to move on make movies without songs like the one Adoor Gopalakrishnan makes. We need to come up with new ideas, use ideas which have clinical evidence- proven and use it with our experience and the most important organ of the therapist - well not the hands, the brain.
Every blog i am going to close with a quote from hero- Homer Simpson
Facts are meaningless. You could use facts to prove anything that's even remotely true! --Homer Simpson

 love 
Hariohm



Friday, 3 January 2014

hi

Hi
 
   After countless push from Prakash V I am starting my blog today. As this is going to be my first I am going to make it simple and non-controversial as possible.
I was having my usual weekly conversation with my friend on –well what else physiotherapy and overall lack of scientific backing for some of our physiotherapeutic techniques.
The question in our mind was why we are unable to move on. You learn something in a particular point of time say manual therapy or NDT and when you see the idea is outdated or the treatment is plain useless we still can’t get over it. Even intelligent therapists seem to be stuck in the time warp. I have seen experts in neurology unable to come to terms with moving of science and time. The common example I use to stress this is the prevalence of normalization, thinking purely mechanical and searching for that one treatment which will bring about the magic touch and heal. (Will write about “hands on” some other time.)
One of the theories we came to is “film music theory” of why we wont move on. The theory is fairly simple in Tamil film industry we have serious film makers who want to make neo-realism movies, but can’t get out of the idea of not having music. Even though it not in the “proper” to have songs in neo-realism they can’t seem to do it because of the 100 years of tradition have making crappy movies with songs.
Likewise in this age of evidence informed practice (EIP) we still can’t come out of NDT if you treat children with cerebral palsy.  This is exploited by the companies which sell these course- and they have “certified tutors”- whatever that means (still can’t understand to teach some techniques why you need to certified- that to a treatment which can be taught in 15 minutes). They charge up to  2 lakhs if they come in a plane from North America- they still teach you the same crap they taught you in your UG- well no one learns anything in PG.
Why this fascination with un-scientific courses, is it because we have to have songs in our movies come what may.