Sunday, 8 May 2022

do I have free will?

 One of the questions I have struggled - philosophically is do we have free will. I always thought we had, We choose what to do or think. The arguments for and against are complex and found it to be fascinating.

Scientist like Robert Sapolsky argue it is not. Philosopher and neuroscientist Sam Harris and Indian non-duality philosophy also seem to suggest we may not have free will. without getting deep into the neuroscience or non-duality ( i could suggest any person with a inclination towards god to read non-duality) - it basically says the neuro-chemistry of our brain decides what we do or think, That neuro-chemistry in turn might be a product of millions of years of evolution to other contextual factors which helped in making that chemistry of your brain.

I know it sounds stupid- as we all think, "i" made that choice. I made the choice to drink coffee in the morning, when to start brushing my teeth, what I wanted to say to the person who stepped on me on the bus or not to say and much more.

Well, I have come to agree with Sam Harris and Sapolsky and probably some ideas of non-duality. Just to be clear, i have lots of trouble understanding Non-duality. There is no free will- ideas, thoughts all seem emerge. 

When you suffer from depression you realize the thoughts which come are not what you want. Harder your try to suppress, you realize you don't have free will. You watch a movie- your mind drifts and even though you are bombarded by the visual and auditory signals from your movie- you are dragged into the rabbit hole. Unlike Alice you don't go to wonderland, you end up where your mind wants to take.

You want to be happy your wife is trying her best, you can see you are hurting everyone- you mind keep on pulling you into the rabbit hole, You see your friends trying hard - sadly your are still being pulled into the rabbit hole. you see good in the world, people trying hard to accommodate you, you should be happy, but the mind pulls into into the darker creeks. harder you try harder it is to control.

Again, you cant choose to secrete more or less or change your brains thinking, because we don't know how our mind works. so how do we control. What we don't know, what is not under your control. I don't-  don't have free will, 

Think of it from your own experience- The time you had flooded with testosterones, when you were in love for the first time, the time you were angry- your actions were different, you thinking was different-sadly other times we think we are in control of our brain. 

Please note the actions i have made, the people i have hurt, the loved ones- my son and my wife's suffering cannot be absolved by saying i don't have free will.  That is for another time to discuss. 

This is just to explain to myself, just like your cant control your pancreas or kidneys or your heart- you cant control your brain as hard you may try. I know you say- i have control- i made a choice- that i dont disagree- its just that your brain was developed like that for millions of years. Dont think because you did it, i can do it. I am not you. I weep, i can be rude to anyone, I can love without any reservations, be indifferent to loving people, thinking people are boring especially pretty ones - I bet you cant do any of that.

love

Hariohm


No- homer simpsons this time rather 3 important people










Thursday, 5 May 2022

Anhedonia

 One of the symptoms of depression is - Anhedonia. That is the first thing i was educated by my psychiatrist. It basically means you dont get pleasure from things which used to. Moreover you lose interest in things which you used to have.

In my case- people who know me will know- i lost interest in movies and TV. I am huge cinephile, even though lately i dont watch formula movies either assembled in Hollywood or in my home town. When i stopped watching TV- i felt so much time in my hand. So much time. When i got depressed i did not know what to do with my time. The ruminations in the mind which is a horrendous  feature of clinical depression, it pitches a tent and does not move. Sadly as the ruminations is not about times you were happy or had some pleasurable experience- it is about the deepest darkest thing in the brain. It ruminates until you want to dig a hole in your brain and remove it.

The second thing i loved and still the only thing i can do better than anyone is Physiotherapy. Sadly it went for a toss. I stopped talking with prakash about PT- which we do nearly every day. I lost interest  in the puzzles- albeit small puzzles, PT threw at me. More time for rumination, more and more the mind went to the darker places.

You may think deriving pleasure from the morning coffee, the perfected baked fish you cooked, the small high you get when you impressed a pretty girl, the captive audience, the thankfulness in your patients face when they feel better- is all small. It is not- i know because i felt it when i lost it. Smaller things is what makes us happy, the small gestures, the routine- sadly it gets lost in depression.

I dont know how you can make someone with depression get it back, i am not sure it can be. I am saying this so that you get what they go through. dont try to force them, be patient, dont be an ass and feel pity- we all want understanding not pity.

Love

Hariohm








Sunday, 10 April 2022

Depression and other disabilities

 I was diagnosed with choric depression and anxiety some years back (5 if i remember correctly). I have tried being open about my symptoms and difficulties it brings about. I should thank my wife to make me come out and be open about it as mental illness.

For quite sometime i started having difficulty in talking to "new" people. It just feels difficult to connect with people.  I have been catastrophizing about seeing people, especially newer people.( sorry what and why i am catastrophizing is between me and my therapist). Anyhow that lead to me stopping from going to Bangalore for some CME and a 2 day workshop. After these happened in the 3 - 2 months back, i thought, i accepted to do one in Chennai itself- a workshop and a one hour talk. Well i would not make that also. 

I am hoping i will be okay in some weeks, as i have accepted to do a talk at the end of this month- hahaha. I know what you are thinking why and who is still calling you after all these. 😏 Well i had accepted this month ends lecture some months back so, i am going to try hard.

All my adult life i have done mostly is talking about PT. It sort of comes easy for me to give lectures- even though lots of people may not like what i deliver or how i deliver. So it is frustrating for me not able to do some stupid lectures on stroke, LBP or EBM. well anyway- that's what i am struggling from.

Even though, i have these nightmare, i am blessed with family, and friends who stand by me. The unanswered phone calls, the constant sleeping, the mood swings, the irrational fear, anger- they have stood by me. I have started again with my meditation which i had stopped, so hoping that will help, probably have to do more, we will see.  


If you are out there struggling with depression, or mental health issues- seek help. nothing to be ashamed of, just like your pancreas has trouble with secreting insulin, you brain is not secreting certain hormones, that is all. 

Hopefully i should write more to create awareness.

Love
Hariohm



Tuesday, 13 April 2021

can you help me publish

 Happy new year,


One of the common pressure on academic staff is "publishing". Even though none of the colleges or universities have zero infrastructure for research (well even for teaching they dont have so) they want all the teaching staff to publish. well as that number is used to "rank" the universities it seems this is not going to end anytime soon

Luckily we have published some studies in good journals, lot of people think i have some secret sauce. so they ask me to help me in publishing. so this post is about that.


well at the outset i want to say- the question is wrong- you need to ask me how to do a "study". Even for that question i may have little value- as whatever i say your guide may not accept- so it is a waste of both of our time.

But i can tell you the 3 important  steps in publishing in a good journal

1, if you do the study you can publish 

2. if you do the study you can publish

3. if you do the study you can publish.



So that is our secret sauce - nothing more nothing less




Friday, 12 March 2021

Maths with health science, coming soon Engineering without maths

 Education is learning without "experience". If you learn only through experience you just need apprenticeship.

Sadly most of education in colleges is so useless we cannot learn without experience. One of the reasons for that (in health science) is we dont learn maths or logical thinking or economics. So we cant understand simple things like probability, difference between single event and generalization. When the pandemic hit most of us in the health services had little idea on what the data was telling us.

Everyday some drug was touted to be a "good" for the covid. as we have no understanding of evolutionary biology we were astonished when the virus mutated to one of the treatment. In a idea situation before generalizing the usage we should have done a trial or an experiment. alas as we "know" it might work. as we think it is better to do something than wait, we ended up with all idiotic ideas. moreover none of the people who told us to be at home (remember they all had a fat cheque) told us how will people eat, how will they go home etc. as we have little understanding of sociology and economics- two important eyes of health. the list goes on. So pray tell me what is your point- after ruining health education with useless syllabus without useful science subjects like maths, physics etc, Now it is striking the Engineering education, you dont have to do maths and physics and join Enginerring. I for one in all my 14 years of experience in the world convinced my mother to for go maths in 11 and 12. I do still suffer and had and still have tough time understanding certain maths which is needed to study neurology leave alone research methods. So what will happens to these students when they dont know laws of thermodyanamics or calculus and want to work in a proper engineering company. How will they work big data or AI? I shudder
Meet our new policy- hope this will be scraped soon

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/education/news/maths-physics-not-a-must-for-engineering-aicte/articleshow/81457412.cms

Sunday, 7 March 2021

where are the women?

 as usual let us remember women on only on women's days. in other days we can forget they do everything- especially for lower wages or no wages.
The other day a photos of principals in TN


What is obvious is it has become a mens club. where are the MS. mary chidambarams of my generation? Well i dont know? suddenly all the students in the class are girls and the women in leadership roles have gone. I am open to why that is.


Saturday, 6 March 2021

ask IAP

 I heard the TNIAP is going to have a discussion in Coimbatore. even though i think these are absolutely useless as there will be one thing on everyone's mind- why the fuck- not everyone is calling us as "doctor". and then start blaming "others".

But that aside i think it is better idea- even though i am highly skeptical
But if you are attending these meetings- the questions i hope someone will ask?
1. who are the people who pressurized, incentivized students to attend the IAP conference
2. okay the students attended it- did those people give a rats ass the students did not get any food?
3. I am assuming around 1 crore was looted in the name of conference (inviting law suit from criminals who ate the money from the president of IAP to MR. desikamani and Co) has any steps taken any action ?
4, if you will not protect "your" students what the hell are we going to do with a association?
5. what steps are taken to stop this loot in the next conference?
6. Then we can discuss whether we are the royal highness or PTs
7. I sincerely believe if we dont do anything -we will have 300- 500 people voting and no one caring about associations
8. i hope people also discuss beyond the same stale issues - like council and talk real issues
9. if you are young if someone tells you council will change PT is TN - run, run like hell - idiocy is contagious